Commentary: Catching COVID-19 is not 'inevitable' and we should still be careful
As the Omicron virus races through populations, some feel it is better to just accept everyone will be infected at some point but two New Zealand researchers say not all infections are equal.
AUCKLAND: New Zealand has entered new COVID-19 territory, characterised by high vaccination rates but also the rapid spread of the Omicron variant and rising numbers of hospitalisations.
As we approach the peak of this wave, some have suggested that it would be better to drop the remaining public health measures, let the infection rip through our population and accept that nearly all of us will get infected very soon. This is unwise for many reasons.
First, simple measures, which we can all take, will ensure that even in this big wave of infections, most of us can still avoid getting infected. Even if you share a household with an infected person, international studies show that the risk of catching the virus is somewhere between 15 per cent and 50 per cent.
Second, not all infections are equal.
The Delta variant is still circulating and we can’t presume that all infections are Omicron. While less virulent than Delta, Omicron can nevertheless cause severe disease and death, particularly among the unvaccinated who make up 3 per cent of the vaccine-eligible population but 19.4 per cent of hospitalisations.
There are still many vulnerable people in the community that we can protect by limiting the spread of the virus and ensuring that they are less likely to encounter it.
Another reason to limit potentially infectious contact is that an infection is more likely if an individual is exposed to a higher initial dose of the virus. An infection avoided or delayed is always a win as we move closer to even more effective vaccines and improved medical treatments for COVID-19.
WHY DO OUTBREAKS COME IN WAVES?
The reason that we get large wave-like outbreaks that rise and fall quickly is because the virus becomes less able to find people to infect as the outbreak progresses. Crucially, this happens before everyone is infected.
This is related to the R number that epidemiologists talk about. R0 is the average number of people that an infectious person infects at the start of an outbreak. When R is greater than one, the number of cases increases, when it is below one, it decreases.
As the outbreak proceeds, more and more people get infected and recover. They cannot immediately be reinfected.
For example, if R is 2 at the start of an outbreak, meaning each case on average transmits to two others, by the time half of the population has been infected and has recovered, the virus will only transmit to one other.
That is because it “tries” to infect two people but finds that, on average, one has already recovered and cannot be reinfected. In this example, the R number is now effectively 1 and infections will start to fall.
OMICRON’S RAPID SPREAD
Despite New Zealand’s high vaccination rates, Omicron is spreading quickly here, as it has in other countries. There are many elements to this.
Omicron is good at avoiding immunity generated by vaccination and previous infection. We have very high rates of first and second doses, but fewer than 60 per cent have received boosters, and we have a very short history of exposure to natural infection.
These characteristics make us prone to a rapid and large outbreak of Omicron. Further, vaccinations, including boosters, are very good at preventing illness, hospitalisation and death, but they don’t prevent infection and transmission quite as well.
This means that even in a highly vaccinated population, you can still get high levels of transmission and infection, but the rates of illness and severe complications will be much lower.
Relaxation of public health measures and the impact of superspreader events may also be contributing to the current picture.
Importantly, while the number of infections has increased dramatically with Omicron, the proportion of these that result in severe complications is much lower than during the earlier Delta outbreak.
What are the challenges Singapore faces in shifting to living with an endemic COVID-19? Listen to CNA's Heart of the Matter:
OUR BEHAVIOUR DETERMINES THE SIZE OF THE WAVE
The earlier cases start to fall, the smaller the overall outbreak will be. If R is 2 at the start of an outbreak, a basic model says around 80 per cent of the population will be infected. If the initial R number can be reduced to 1.5, only 58 per cent of the population get infected.
Luckily, we exert some control over the R number. Measures like mask-wearing, good use of ventilation, self-isolation when symptomatic or after a positive test, vaccination and avoiding crowded indoor areas all work to reduce R and the total number of people who will get infected.
Local modeling suggests that depending on how well we adopt these measures, somewhere between 25 per cent and 60 per cent of the population are likely to be infected in this outbreak.
Even when sharing the same household as a case, it is not inevitable everyone else will get infected. Studies from the UK, Denmark and South Korea have all looked at the probability of susceptible people in the same household as a positive case getting infected.
They found that with Omicron, this probability is somewhere between 15 per cent and 50 per cent. In other words, you still have a better than even chance of avoiding infection through your infectious housemate.
All the measures that work generally to reduce spread also work within a household. Mask up inside, get air flowing through, where possible move the infected household member into their own bedroom and bathroom and practise good basic hygiene.
The relationship between the initial exposure dose, infection and disease severity is a property of many infectious diseases, including respiratory diseases in humans and other animals.
A recent review concluded that while there is good evidence of a direct relationship between the COVID-19 virus dose and infection in humans, evidence for a link between dose and severity is lacking, despite some evidence from animal models.
COVID-19 severity is most likely driven by factors other than the initial exposure dose. These include the virus variant and host factors such as age or the presence of some pre-existing health conditions.
All the standard public and personal health measures will help us avoid getting infected and reduce transmission to the more vulnerable, thereby reducing the number of people with severe illnesses.
David Welch is a senior lecturer at the University of Auckland and Nigel French is a Professor of Food Safety and Veterinary Public Health at Massey University. This commentary first appeared in The Conversation.