Skip to main content
Hamburger Menu Close



Commentary: Biggest risk employees face is not replacement by machines but being treated like one

PwC offers a fitness watch to monitor employees’ wellbeing but it would be easy to misuse such insights, says the Financial Times’ Pilita Clark.

Commentary: Biggest risk employees face is not replacement by machines but being treated like one

Woman looking tired working from home (Photo: iStock)

LONDON: If you ever bump into Kevin Ellis, the 58-year-old boss of PwC UK, take a look at his right wrist.

On it, there will almost certainly be one of those fitness watch gadgets that people wear to see how fast their heart is beating and whether they walked as much on Tuesday as they did on Monday.

In this case, it is a Garmin Vivosmart 4 tracker and Ellis keeps it strapped on in bed, in the shower and of course when he is trotting off to reach his goal of 600 “intensity minutes” of exercise each week.

“The only time I take it off is for a recharge,” he said the other day, adding he thought most of his board at the accountancy group had been wearing the devices as well. “I didn’t ask the board to do it,” he said. “Everyone was just interested.”

Well they might be, since Ellis’s Garmin is not exactly what it seems.

READ: Commentary: Call me a strawberry millennial, but being passionate doesn’t mean I’m willing to be exploited


It is one of 1,000 fitness trackers PwC offered to its UK staff last year, after the first COVID-19 lockdowns began, to test an algorithmic system like few others.

Think of it as a “Fitbit on steroids”, said Rob McCargow, PwC UK’s director of artificial intelligence.

Unlike other digital “wearables” that merely spit out numbers for their users, the Garmin data goes into a platform PwC designed jointly with IHP Analytics, a company that has worked with Formula 1 motor racing and other elite sports bodies keen to advance performance.

The platform also takes in data from watch wearers’ time sheets and work calendars, as well as the results of psychometric and cognitive tests.

READ: Commentary: Why some workers in Singapore can’t wait to return to the office

Once all this is fed through an algorithm, the system is supposed to give each user a better sense of their sleep patterns, stress levels and overall well-being.

Individual data is only available to the person wearing the Garmin, said McCargow. But it is anonymised and collated to show managers how the whole organisation is faring.

It has revealed, for example, that sedentary behaviour at the company shot up by at least 25 per cent after lockdowns started. (A smaller pilot before the pandemic enabled a comparison to be made.)

A man tracking his fitness. (Photo: iStock)

Worker stress levels also fell after pubs reopened and rose during peak performance review periods, which may bolster efforts to spread workloads more evenly throughout the year.


Surprised? Maybe not. But as more companies experiment with hybrid ways of working,

PwC thinks there will be rising demand for tools like this that can check on workers’ welfare in real time and see, for instance, if rolling out meditation app subscriptions really makes a difference.

“I can see clients taking this on as a way of attracting staff,” said Ellis, who is keen to stress the watch is not compulsory. “We’re not talking about some kind of Big Brother monitoring.”

READ: Commentary: Fresh grads should see short-term contracts, internships as stepping stones

PwC was criticised last year for developing a facial recognition tool that could track financial services staff working at home. But its new system is set to expand. Up to 5,000 more fitness watches are due to be rolled out soon and strong demand is expected: Staff snapped up last year’s 1,000 Garmins in less than four hours.


Yet it is hard to be entirely convinced about this sort of platform. Workplace technology is not necessarily bad if deployed well, and a big company such as PwC is likely to use it for the good of its workers.

But there is no guarantee its clients will. A few days after I spoke to Kevin Ellis, news broke that spyware made by an Israeli company that was supposed to tackle terrorism had instead been traced to the phones of dissidents and journalists.

READ: Commentary: The coming resignation tsunami - why many may leave their jobs in a pandemic economy

Also, the digital leash is already being tugged ever tighter on some workers in what one recent report has called the Amazonian era of work. “The techniques and tools of the gig economy have spread far beyond gig work,” says the study from the UK’s Institute for the Future of Work.

“Algorithmic systems are being used across the economy to control fundamental aspects of work,” it warns, undermining efforts to improve wellbeing.

Supermarket workers and lorry drivers have borne the brunt of this shift so far. But for lawyers and accountants too, it may turn out the biggest risk they face is not being replaced by machines, but being treated just like them.

Source: Financial Times/sl