Commentary: COVID-19 vaccines for the youngest children inch towards authorisation
With Moderna seeking emergency use authorisation in the United States for children aged six and below, a paediatric professor looks at whether the vaccine will be safe for the youngest children.
CHARLOTTESVILLE, Virginia: For some parents of young children, the wait for COVID-19 vaccines has been long and agonising. Throughout 2021, vaccines against COVID-19 emerged as the most effective way to prevent severe forms of the disease.
Vaccines are currently recommended for everyone five years and older in the United States but are not yet available for younger age groups. Though rarer in young children, severe disease leading to hospitalisation and even death from COVID-19 can occur.
Recent US rates of COVID-associated hospitalisation in those under five have been the highest on record, as a result of the surge in cases from the highly transmissible Omicron variant. Hospitalisations escalated to 14.8 per 100,000 people in January, five times higher than during the Delta variant surge in September 2021.
Safe and effective vaccines for young children offer the prospect of protection and limit disruptions to childcare and early childhood educational opportunities.
As a paediatrician specialising in infectious diseases, I have cared for many children with COVID-19 at our medical centre. I have also had the opportunity to frequently spend time talking to parents about how to make the best choices to protect their young children from COVID-19.
Here’s the latest on the clinical trials and formal review process for vaccines for this important group of patients.
LOWER EFFICACY IN YOUNGEST CHILDREN SO FAR
On Mar 23, Moderna released the interim results of its trials for young children, which included the enrollment of 6,700 children aged six months to six years old. Moderna administered the vaccine in two doses to the children, giving the kids in this age group one-fourth the adult dose.
The company reported robust antibody responses comparable to what they saw in young adults between 18 and 25 years old. During the Omicron surge, however, efficacy against infection was 44 per cent in children six months to under two years and 38 per cent in children between two and six, the company said.
On the same day, Moderna announced that it is moving ahead with seeking emergency use authorisation from the Food and Drug Administration (FDA) for use of the vaccine.
Shortly before, during the height of the Omicron surge, Pfizer-BioNTech, the company whose COVID-19 vaccine is the only one currently available for US children and adolescents over five years old, applied to the FDA to expand emergency use authorisation of its COVID-19 vaccine for use in children under the age of five. The kids in this part of their trial were given one-tenth the dose given to adults and teens.
CNA's Heart of the Matter unpacks the data, the fears and the choice parents need to make in vaccinating their young children:
Pfizer had previously announced that while two shots of this low dose of its vaccine generated antibody responses comparable to older groups in children ages six months to two years, adequate antibody responses did not develop in children ages two to five years.
A three-dose series for all young children is now being tested. The FDA has deferred its review of Pfizer’s emergency use authorisation request until the third-dose data is available, which is expected in early April.
ADJUSTMENTS TO ACCOMMODATE YOUNG IMMUNE SYSTEMS
COVID-19 vaccines have proved highly effective in the prevention of severe COVID-19 in adults and older children. Prior to use, all vaccines go through rigorous testing in clinical trials, first in adults and then in children, recognising that there may be biological differences in immune response for different age groups.
Going down sequentially in age allows investigators and regulators to evaluate the optimal dose with the least number of side effects.
Both Moderna and Pfizer have tested their vaccines by age groups. The ongoing Pfizer trial for those under 12 years began in March 2021, following evaluation in adults and older teens and then 12 to 15 year olds, for example.
Children five to 11 next received one-third the dose that was given to adults and teens as two doses, which produced similarly high levels of protective antibody responses compared to 16 to 25 year olds. Based on the robust immune response and safety established in this trial, the FDA expanded its emergency use authorisation for children five to 11 in October 2021.
However, more recent work, including a study that is not yet peer-reviewed, suggests that waning vaccine effectiveness during the Omicron variant surge, with a more pronounced decline over time in children aged 5 to 11.
Reassuringly, protection against hospitalisation remained strong, and boosters improved protection among eligible older teens. Pfizer and Moderna are planning to evaluate booster doses in children.
Optimisation of doses and intervals in all age groups may help maintain higher levels of protection in the face of the omicron variant.
IMMUNE RESPONSES MAY DIFFER IN AGE GROUPS
Vaccines work by teaching the immune system to make disease-fighting antibodies. Several factors determine how our bodies respond to vaccines, and one of these variables is age. Vaccine responses in particular may differ in the very young when immune systems may have less memory.
Testing by age groups helps to account for these differences in how the maturing immune system responds to different types of vaccines. It is common for childhood vaccines to be given in a series to help train the young immune response to make better and stronger antibody responses with each subsequent dose.
Trials also evaluate vaccine reactions by age. Most COVID-19 vaccine side effects have been mild and short-lived, such as pain at the injection site.
Pfizer and Moderna both report that their COVID-19 vaccines are similarly well-tolerated in the youngest age groups. Moderna reports that the frequency of fever is similar to other pediatric vaccines.
Even after trials are complete and vaccines are authorised or approved, safety monitoring continues. This allows even very rare side effects to be detected.
One such example is myocarditis, or inflammation of the heart, which can occur in rare cases following COVID-19 vaccination. Reports indicate that these cases typically responded well to supportive care and resolved rapidly.
Few adverse events were reported among nearly 8 million vaccine doses given to those aged five to 11, indicating even lower rates in this age group compared to in ages 12 and above.
Outside of infancy, when babies may be born with congenital heart problems, myocarditis is generally uncommon in younger age groups, so it may prove to be rare following vaccination in young children.
If the FDA grants emergency use authorisation of a COVID-19 shot for children under five years of age following its upcoming review, it will clear the way for the vaccine to be distributed nationwide in the US.
The next step will be for the Centers for Disease Control and Prevention to endorse its use for the 18 million US children in this age group – a decision that has usually come within days of FDA authorisation for COVID-19 vaccines.
Young infants under the age of six months are not currently included in the vaccine clinical trials, but antibodies produced by mothers from vaccination in pregnancy can be passed on through the placenta to provide protection from COVID-19 during the first few months of life.
Debbie-Ann Shirley is an Associate Professor of Pediatrics at the University of Virginia. This commentary first appeared in The Conversation.