Commentary: Sleep-deprived healthcare workers and paramedics can’t care for patients to the best of their abilities
Overworked healthcare professionals can be less empathetic towards patients’ needs, says a neuroscience researcher.
CALGARY, Canada: A lack of sleep affects people’s ability to feel for others. Sleep deprivation and emotional fatigue can hit anyone, but first responders and healthcare workers are especially vulnerable due to shift work, long hours and the overall stressful nature of their jobs.
This is relevant during a pandemic when the healthcare systems of many countries have been overwhelmed by the increasing number of people in hospitals.
Our research found that sleep-deprived paramedics are less able to understand how their patients feel.
IMPACT OF SLEEP LOSS ON MOOD AND EMOTIONS
When you don’t sleep, you can’t react as quickly, remember information, solve problems, make plans, multitask or regulate and understand emotions as well as you could if you were well rested. It’s well known that not getting enough sleep alters mood and emotions — think how grumpy you feel the next day if you stay up all night.
But we know less about how lack of sleep impacts more complex emotional processes. Moods and emotions are often thought of as the same thing. In reality, they are very different.
Moods are short-lived, aren’t linked to a particular event and are either positive or negative. The last time you had a “mood swing”, you probably felt great and then terrible, but may not have been able to pinpoint the cause.
Emotions are learned responses to situations or people. They come in different shades and intensities. For example, the emotion of fear may come at the sight of a bear in the woods.
It’s hard enough to understand our own emotions, but what about understanding other people’s emotions?
SLEEP LOSS AFFECTS EMPATHY
Empathy is the ability to understand someone else’s emotions, to put yourself in someone else’s shoes.
In 2014, in collaboration with Neurolab, directed by cognitive neuroscience professor Giuseppe Iaria, we designed a study to understand how a single night without sleep would impact people’s ability to understand the emotions of others.
We developed a computer test that shows participants images of people in negative, positive and neutral situations, for example, people in pain, people laughing and dancing or people just sitting at a table. We then asked participants to first describe what the people in the photo were feeling and then how strong their own emotions were while looking at the pictures.
We used this test to measure empathy in a group of university students. First we tested everyone to understand how empathetic they were normally. Then we had a group spend the night in the lab where we kept them awake by playing board games, socialising and watching movies.
After they had been awake all night, we re-tested them and compared their results to students who were sent home to have a good night of sleep.
Healthcare professionals are still fighting COVID-19 after 20 months on the frontlines. Two doctors weigh in on how hospitals are coping with the recent surge on CNA's Heart of the Matter:
Our findings were clear: Sleep-deprived students felt less empathy for people in negative situations than students who had had a good night’s sleep.
But is it only extreme sleep deprivation, like staying up all night, that triggers this change?
POOR SLEEP QUALITY IN PARAMEDICS
We found that chronic poor sleep quality was also linked with lower empathy for others. One group of people that experiences chronic sleep loss due to job schedule is paramedics.
Following a shift work schedule for many years affects paramedics’ sleep quality. Paramedics are also the first to respond to patients in stressful and traumatic situations, so having empathy is an important part of their job.
Using the same computer task we previously used with students, we tested paramedics with more than five years of experience and trainees who were studying to become paramedics.
Experienced paramedics reported poor quality of sleep and low empathy compared to trainees. They also told us about their years of sleep issues and how they felt numb to other people’s pain.
Emotional numbing, lack of empathy and sleep disturbances are some of the symptoms experienced by people who suffer from post-traumatic stress disorder (PTSD). These symptoms increase the risk of suicide.
According to Canadian statistics from the Centre for Suicide Prevention, first responders are twice as likely to experience PTSD than the general population. About 22 per cent of paramedics will develop PTSD at some point in their life.
During the coronavirus pandemic frontline workers worldwide are experiencing more symptoms of insomnia, anxiety, depression and PTSD. Recent media coverage has helped bring this to the public’s attention, reporting on a dramatic shortage of staff and poor working conditions in many provinces in Canada during the third and fourth waves. However, policymakers tend to fall behind.
Our research shows that overworked healthcare professionals are less empathetic to their patients’ needs compared to when they are well-rested. This finding should guide policy to ensure our healthcare workers get the rest they need to help their patients to the best of their abilities.
Veronica Guadagni is a postdoctoral fellow in cognitive neuroscience at the University of Calgary. This commentary first appeared on The Conversation.