Skip to main content
Hamburger Menu Close



Over-the-counter cough mixtures: Do they actually work better than tea and honey?

Evidence is sorely lacking for the value of any over-the-counter remedy to treat most coughs.

Over-the-counter cough mixtures: Do they actually work better than tea and honey?

(Art: The New York Times/Gracia Lam)

On a South American trip last month with two of my grandsons, the younger – 14-year-old Tennyson – developed a cough.

He had no fever, congestion or fatigue, said he felt fine, ate and slept normally and stayed well-hydrated.

But eight days later, after watching a live raptor show for 90 minutes in freezing winds, his cough was noticeably worse.

As the responsible adult, I decided to get him an over-the-counter cough medicine – the Ecuadorean version of Robitussin DM.

I now know that my grandmother’s remedy of chicken soup or tea with honey, or perhaps a syrup with sweetened cocoa powder, as a new study found, might have been a better choice to soothe his irritated airways.

Coughs are one of the leading reasons for visits to the doctor and trips to the drugstore, where shelf-long displays of non-prescription cough medicines can overwhelm even the most discerning consumer.

Yet, evidence is sorely lacking for the value of any over-the-counter remedy to treat most coughs, be they wet or dry.

More likely, any significant benefit people get from cough medicine is probably due primarily to the placebo effect: You think – you hope – it will help, so it does, at least temporarily.

But even when cough medicines help a little, they do not cure or shorten the duration of a cough.

People anxious for relief and convinced that cough medicines should work buy them anyway, Dr Norman Edelman, a pulmonologist at Stony Brook University School of Medicine and scientific adviser at the American Lung Association, told me.

READ: Is your family in perpetual flu hell? Women may suffer from it more than men

He’s not suggesting that cough medicines don’t work at all, just that there is as yet no proof that they do.

They are not totally free of side effects, however rare, and some can be hazardous for people with health problems like high blood pressure or congestive heart failure.

And, as their labels state, they should never be given to children younger than four.

In fact, the American Academy of Pediatrics says there’s no reason to use them in children under six.

Because manufacturers try to hit all bases, over-the-counter cough remedies most often contain combinations of three or four ingredients when a patient may need only one or two.

Typical ingredients include a cough suppressant, an expectorant and an antihistamine, when better hydration or drinking hot tea with honey may be all someone really needs to quell a nagging cough.

I haven’t had occasion to try this yet, but Dr Alyn Morice, a respiratory specialist at the University of Hull and founding member of the International Society for the Study of Cough, recently cited a randomised controlled trial involving 163 patients that showed a chocolate-based cough medicine to be superior to standard cough remedies.

The explanation: Cocoa has demulcent properties.

That is, it soothes irritated mucous membranes by forming a protective film, covering nerve endings that trigger the urge to cough.

Under normal circumstances, a cough is a very useful reflex that can help to clear the airways of mucus or an irritating substance, and prevent debris or liquids from getting through to the lungs.

Coughs become especially troublesome when they linger for weeks on end or when a sudden tickle triggers a coughing fit in the middle of a play, concert or lecture.

(Word to the wise: Always come equipped with cough drops that can be opened quietly and, if possible, a small bottle of water to squelch a disruptive cough that won’t quit on its own.)

READ: Headaches: When should you take a painkiller or see a doctor?

Most lingering coughs are the residual effect of a cold or flu, and they can last for weeks and weeks, get better or worse, and still not represent anything more than a nuisance, Dr Edelman said.

But the misery associated with coughs sends more than 30 million people to the doctor every year.

And there are certainly circumstances under which a doctor should be consulted.

Among them, Dr Edelman said, are patients with underlying medical conditions like COPD (chronic obstructive pulmonary disease) or asthma, even mild cases of asthma.

“People with asthma should have an action plan established in consultation with their doctor – what to do ‘in case’ a cough develops,” he said.

“It’s best to catch it early, when the inflammation just starts because it’s harder to treat when it’s well established.”

He added: “People with a significant underlying health problem should not wait four weeks to see a doctor.” 

Other circumstances that warrant medical attention include persistent coughs that interfere with the ability to sleep; coughs associated with fever, chills and feeling unwell; and coughs that produce blood in the sputum.

Then, there are the coughs that become chronic, persisting beyond eight or more weeks.

They could result from an irritated, inflamed airway that may require treatment with an inhaled corticosteroid to reduce the inflammation, Dr Edelman said.

Writing in the New England Journal Of Medicine, Dr Ashley Woodcock and Jaclyn Smith estimated that chronic cough affects “as much as 12 per cent of the general population”.

It affects more women than men, most often in their 40s and 50s, and can persist for years “with substantial physical, social and psychological effects”, they wrote.

In addition to respiratory diseases like asthma, possible causes of chronic cough include a persistent postnasal drip that may result from an allergy, sinus infection, airborne irritant or even exposure to very dry cold air.

Depending on the cause, the best treatment may involve an oral antihistamine, nose drops, a vaporiser or, if an infection is found, antibiotics.

READ: Is it safe to drink alcohol while taking antibiotics?

But Dr Edelman warned against using a humidifier with a water reservoir that can become contaminated with a fungus, unless it is thoroughly cleaned daily.

Also, overly humidifying the air can foster dust mites, which are common allergens.

Another often unrecognised cause of chronic cough is GERD, or gastroesophageal reflux disease.

Sometimes, this condition is not apparent during waking hours, but reflux may occur during sleep, resulting in inhalation of a bit of regurgitated stomach contents, or causing a reflex that constricts the airways, Dr Edelman explained.

Sometimes, chronic cough can be a side effect of drug treatments like ACE inhibitors used to treat high blood pressure.

Prolonged bouts of coughing can have their own complications, including stress urinary incontinence, muscle pain, cracked ribs and occasionally retching and vomiting.

By Jane Brody © The New York Times

This article originally appeared in The New York Times.

Source: New York Times